Validation log

Append-only audit trail of every source and claim validation performed on the Kipine knowledge base. Each row records who (AI model or human), when, and what was verified — with the evidence snippet from the source when available. This is the transparency layer behind every "Verified" badge you see elsewhere on the site.

170 total events166 sources checked2 claims checkedpartial: 1pass: 169claude-opus-4-6: 5crossref-api: 2pubmed-api: 162tatu: 1

How validation works

Every validation event is written as one line in an append-only JSONL log. Nothing is ever overwritten — if a prior check turns out to be wrong, a new event is added that supersedes the old one. Each event records the validator (specific AI model version, human reviewer, or deterministic API lookup), the prompt hash used, the tools invoked, and — for claim-level checks — the exact quote from the source that supports the claim. See the full design in research/VALIDATION_DESIGN.md.

Event log

  1. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 08:55 PMby pubmed-api

    Replaced a fabricated citation with the real source for this claim (resolved by topic + PubMed/Crossref): HLA-DRB1, -DQA1, and -DQB1 genotypes in patients with nasal polyposis.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  2. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 08:55 PMby pubmed-api

    Replaced a fabricated citation with the real source for this claim (resolved by topic + PubMed/Crossref): Superantigens and nasal polyps.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  3. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 08:55 PMby pubmed-api

    Replaced a fabricated citation with the real source for this claim (resolved by topic + PubMed/Crossref): Immunopathogenesis of Chronic Rhinosinusitis and Nasal Polyposis.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  4. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 08:55 PMby pubmed-api

    Confirmed as the real support for the NLRP3-inflammasome-in-AOSD claim (Hsieh 2017, already cited as B4); removed a redundant fabricated duplicate citation (former B5).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  5. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 08:55 PMby pubmed-api

    Replaced a fabricated citation with the real source for this claim (resolved by topic + PubMed/Crossref): Genomewide epigenetic study shows significant DNA hypermethylation in chronic rhinosinusitis versus control ethmoidal tissue.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  6. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 08:55 PMby pubmed-api

    Replaced a fabricated citation with the real source for this claim (resolved by topic + PubMed/Crossref): Inflammatory and homeostatic roles of eosinophil subpopulations in chronic rhinosinusitis with nasal polyp pathogenesis.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  7. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 07:49 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier re-resolved by title: prior entry (pmid-29343482) had a wrong PMID; the Schnitzler gene-panel study is Rowczenio et al., Blood 2018.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  8. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:57 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier re-resolved by title (deeper second pass): prior entry (doi-10-1182-blood-2004-12-4767) had a fabricated/wrong identifier; repointed to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  9. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:57 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier re-resolved by title (deeper second pass): prior entry (pmid-23958647) had a fabricated/wrong identifier; repointed to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  10. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:57 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier re-resolved by title (deeper second pass): prior entry (doi-10-1111-all-14024) had a fabricated/wrong identifier; repointed to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  11. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:57 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier re-resolved by title (deeper second pass): prior entry (doi-10-3390-cancers13133100) had a fabricated/wrong identifier; repointed to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  12. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:57 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier re-resolved by title (deeper second pass): prior entry (doi-10-1016-s0140-6736-23-02873-0) had a fabricated/wrong identifier; repointed to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  13. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID verified correct against PubMed; no DOI exists. Removed a fabricated stored DOI.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  14. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  15. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  16. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  17. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-12393746) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  18. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  19. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  20. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  21. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID verified correct against PubMed; no DOI exists. Removed a fabricated stored DOI.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  22. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  23. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  24. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-15751091) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  25. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  26. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  27. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  28. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  29. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  30. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  31. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  32. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  33. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  34. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  35. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  36. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  37. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  38. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-25320245) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  39. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  40. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  41. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  42. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  43. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  44. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-25624763) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  45. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-26116516) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  46. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  47. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  48. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  49. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  50. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  51. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  52. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  53. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-27708868) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  54. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  55. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-27791120) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  56. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  57. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  58. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  59. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-25498791) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  60. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-36430339) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  61. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  62. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  63. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  64. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-30418119) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  65. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  66. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (doi-10-1016-j-ebiom-2019-04-007) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  67. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-31008176) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  68. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  69. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  70. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  71. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  72. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (doi-10-1016-j-jaci-2020-07-032) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  73. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  74. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  75. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  76. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  77. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  78. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  79. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-34494213) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  80. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  81. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (pmid-35926117) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  82. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  83. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  84. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  85. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Identifier corrected: prior entry (doi-10-1038-s41420-023-01785-6) had a wrong PMID/DOI pointing to an unrelated paper; re-resolved by title to this record via PubMed/Crossref.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  86. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  87. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  88. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 04:40 PMby pubmed-api

    Stored DOI was incorrect; corrected to the PubMed-registered DOI (verified to resolve to this article).

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  89. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 02:25 PMby pubmed-api

    DOI corrected to the PubMed/Crossref-registered value; the prior stored DOI was fabricated (resolved to an unrelated or non-existent article). A duplicate entry carrying a malformed PMID was removed from the manifest.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  90. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 02:25 PMby pubmed-api

    DOI corrected to the PubMed/Crossref-registered value; the prior stored DOI was fabricated (resolved to an unrelated or non-existent article). A duplicate entry carrying a malformed PMID was removed from the manifest.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  91. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 02:25 PMby pubmed-api

    DOI corrected to the PubMed/Crossref-registered value; the prior stored DOI was fabricated (resolved to an unrelated or non-existent article). A duplicate entry carrying a malformed PMID was removed from the manifest.

    tools: pubmed.esummary, crossref.works

  92. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    Matched to a PubMed record by title + author during Issue-3 backfill; PMID and DOI resolved from PubMed E-utilities.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  93. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    Matched to a PubMed record by title + author during Issue-3 backfill; PMID and DOI resolved from PubMed E-utilities.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  94. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    Matched to a PubMed record by title + author during Issue-3 backfill; PMID and DOI resolved from PubMed E-utilities.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  95. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    Matched to a PubMed record by title + author during Issue-3 backfill; PMID and DOI resolved from PubMed E-utilities.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  96. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    Matched to a PubMed record by title + author during Issue-3 backfill; PMID and DOI resolved from PubMed E-utilities.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  97. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby crossref-api

    DOI resolved via Crossref; journal (J Cutan Immunol Allergy) is not MEDLINE-indexed, so no PMID exists.

    tools: crossref.works

  98. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    Matched to a PubMed record by title + author during Issue-3 backfill; PMID and DOI resolved from PubMed E-utilities.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  99. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby crossref-api

    DOI resolved via Crossref; J Am Acad Dermatol 2015 meeting abstract, not indexed in PubMed.

    tools: crossref.works

  100. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    Matched to a PubMed record by title + author during Issue-3 backfill; PMID and DOI resolved from PubMed E-utilities.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  101. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    Matched to a PubMed record by title + author during Issue-3 backfill; PMID resolved (no DOI registered) from PubMed E-utilities.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  102. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  103. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  104. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  105. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  106. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  107. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  108. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  109. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  110. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  111. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  112. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  113. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  114. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  115. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  116. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  117. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  118. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  119. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  120. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  121. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  122. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  123. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  124. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  125. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  126. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  127. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  128. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  129. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  130. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  131. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  132. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  133. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  134. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  135. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  136. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  137. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  138. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  139. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  140. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  141. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  142. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  143. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  144. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  145. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  146. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  147. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  148. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  149. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID corrected to 30985672 (Ruscitti et al., Medicine 2019); prior PMID 30767868 was a mismatched record. DOI resolved from PubMed E-utilities.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  150. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  151. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  152. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  153. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  154. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  155. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  156. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  157. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  158. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  159. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  160. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  161. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  162. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  163. passsource metadatasourceJun 1, 2026, 01:59 PMby pubmed-api

    PMID/DOI resolved and recorded from PubMed E-utilities during SEO DOI backfill.

    tools: pubmed.esummary

  164. passfull reviewsourceApr 8, 2026, 03:20 PMby tatu

    Hand-verified — this is the canonical Strasbourg criteria reference. Evidence grade B is appropriate.

  165. passclaim attributionclaimApr 8, 2026, 02:19 PMby claude-opus-4-6conf 93%
    All patients presented with chronic urticarial lesions as the cardinal dermatologic manifestation.

    Lipsker 2001 original case series; urticaria present in every reported patient.

    tools: pubmed.get_article_metadata

  166. passclaim attributionclaimApr 8, 2026, 02:18 PMby claude-opus-4-6conf 97%
    Chronic urticarial eruption is the clinical hallmark and is observed in 100% of patients with Schnitzler syndrome, constituting one of the two obligate criteria in the Strasbourg system.

    Direct support in de Koning 2014 review abstract and discussion.

    tools: pubmed.get_article_metadata, pubmed.get_full_text_article

  167. partialsource metadatasourceApr 8, 2026, 02:05 PMby claude-opus-4-6conf 85%

    Authors, title, DOI match. Year stored as 2025 but PubMed lists publication date as 2025-09-15 (online ahead of print) — acceptable. Flagging because the systematic review is not yet linked from any diagnostic-criterion claim; see research/updates/schnitzler-syndrome/2026-03-08.md item #2.

    • discrepancy · volume: stored= null · found= "online ahead of print"

    tools: pubmed.get_article_metadata

  168. passsource metadatasourceApr 8, 2026, 02:02 PMby claude-opus-4-6conf 98%

    de Koning et al. 2014 Strasbourg criteria review; all metadata fields match PubMed.

    tools: pubmed.get_article_metadata

  169. passsource accessibilitysourceApr 5, 2026, 09:12 AMby pubmed-api

    Record retrievable from PubMed E-utilities; no retraction notice.

    tools: pubmed.get_article_metadata

  170. passsource metadatasourceApr 5, 2026, 09:12 AMby claude-opus-4-6conf 99%

    PMID resolves; authors, title, journal, year match PubMed exactly.

    tools: pubmed.get_article_metadata